Public Discourse and Category Formation: A Topic Modelling Exploration of ‘Historical Shops’ on Italian Media
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.19245/25.05.pij.5.2.2Keywords:
category, category formation, media discourses, historical shops, topic modelingAbstract
This paper addresses the role of public discourse in processes of category formation. Tracing the emergence and diffusion of a category on the media, and exploring the discourses generated on the media within and around the emerging category, the paper reflects on how these discourses concur in performing the very category they portray. The focus is set on the Historical Shops category, as part of broader processes of urban categorisations for local development and regeneration. By means of a Topic Modelling of a corpus of 3262 press articles collected from Italian news sources between 2009 and 2019, the paper finds that public discourse plays three main roles: echoing category creation processes by policymakers, grounding the rising category in wider discourses of retail crisis, urban degradation, regeneration and overtourism, and narrating it by explaining what Historical Shops are, where they are located, which issues they face and which responses they receive at different institutional levels. Overall, in this paper, the semi-automated techniques afforded by Topic Modelling offer a way to enter the meaning construction processes and elicit the agential role of public discourse in the formation of a category.
References
Benoit, K., Watanabe, K., Wang, H. Nulty, P., Obeng, A., Müller, S., and Matsuo, A. (2018), “Quanteda: An R Package for the Quantitative Analysis of Textual Data”, Journal of Open Source Software, 3 (30): 1-4.
Blei, D.M., and Lafferty, J.D. (2007), “A Correlated Topic Model of Science”, The Annals of Applied Statistics, 1 (1): 17-35.
Blei, D.M., Ng, A.Y., and Jordan, M.I. (2003), “Latent Dirichlet Allocation”, Journal of Machine Learning Research, 3: 993-1022.
Buchanan, S., Ruebottom, T., and Riaz, S. (2018), “Categorizing Competence: Consumer Debt and the Reproduction of Gender-Based Status Differences”, Organization Studies, 39 (9): 1179-1202.
Corbett, A.C., Harley, B., Amason, A.C., Ravasi, D., and Spicer, A. (2013), “Opening up New Vistas in Categorization Research”, Journal of Management Studies, 50 (6): 1097-99.
Chliova, M., Mair, J., and Vernis, A. (2020), “Persistent Category Ambiguity: The Case of Social Entrepreneurship”, Organization Studies, 41 (7): 1019-1042.
Croidieu, G., and Kim, P.H. (2018), “Labour of Love: Amateurs and Lay-Expertise Legitimation in the Early U.S. Radio Field”, Administrative Science Quarterly, 63 (1): 1-42.
Curchod, C., Patriotta, G., and Neysen, N. (2014), “Categorization and Identification: The Identity Work of ‘Business Sellers’ on EBay”, Human Relations, 67 (11): 1293-1320.
Decreto Legislativo 22 Gennaio 2004, n. 42, Codice dei Beni Culturali e del Paesaggio, ai sensi dell’articolo 10 della legge 6 luglio 2002, n. 137.
Decreto Legislativo 25 Novembre 2016, n. 222, Individuazione di Procedimenti Oggetto di Autorizzazione, Segnalazione Certificata di Inizio di Attività (SCIA), Silenzio Assenso e Comunicazione e di Definizione dei Regimi Amministrativi Applicabili a Determinate Attività e Procedimenti, ai sensi dell'articolo 5 della legge 7 Agosto 2015, n. 124. (16G00237) (GU Serie Generale n. 277 del 26/11/2016 - Suppl. Ordinario n. 52).
Decreto Legislativo 31 Marzo 1998, n. 114, Riforma della Disciplina Relativa al Settore del Commercio, a norma dell’art. 4, comma 4, della legge 15 Marzo 1997, n. 59.
Decreto-Legge 30 Aprile 2019, n. 34, Misure Urgenti di Crescita Economica e per la Risoluzione di Specifiche Situazioni di Crisi. (19G00043) (GU Serie Generale n. 100 del 30/04/2019).
Delibera n. 290088/2008, Promozione e Valorizzazione delle Botteghe Storiche e dei Mercati Storici. Approvazione dei Nuovi Criteri di Individuazione, ai sensi della legge della Regione Emilia Romagna n. 5/2008. Istituzione del Nuovo Albo delle Botteghe e dei Mercati Storici, Comune di Bologna, 12/01/2008.
DiMaggio, P., Nag, M., and Blei, D. (2013), “Exploiting Affinities between Topic Modeling and the Sociological Perspective on Culture: Application to Newspaper Coverage of U.S. Government Arts Funding”, Poetics, 41 (6): 570-606.
Durand, R., and Paolella, L. (2013), “Category Stretching: Reorienting Research on Categories in Strategy and Entrepreneurship”, Journal of Management Studies, 50 (6): 1100-1123.
Durand, R., and Khaire, M. (2017), “Where Do Market Categories Come from and How? Distinguishing Category Creation from Category Emergence”, Journal of Management, 43 (1): 87-110.
Estratto dal Verbale delle Deliberazioni del Consiglio Comunale n. 130, Approvazione di Misure di Tutela dei Negozi Storici della Città di Roma, Comune di Roma Capitale, 14/06/2005.
Glynn, M.A., and Navis, C. (2013), “Categories, Identities, and Cultural Classification: Moving beyond a Model of Categorical Constraint”, Journal of Management Studies, 50 (6): 1124-1137.
Granqvist, N., and Ritvala, T. (2016), “Beyond Prototypes: Drivers of Market Categorization in Functional Foods and Nanotechnology”, Journal of Management Studies, 53 (2): 210-237.
Hannigan, T.R., Haans, R.F., Vakili, K., Tchalian, H., Glaser, V.L., Wang, M.S., and Jennings, P.D. (2019), “Topic Modeling in Management Research: Rendering New Theory from Textual Data”, Academy of Management Annals, 13 (2): 586-632.
Hardy, C., and Maguire, S. (2010), “Discourse, Discourse, Field-Configuring Events, and Change in Organizations and Institutional Fields: Narratives of DDT and the Stockholm Convention”, The Academy Of Management Journal, 53 (6): 1365-1392.
Jones, C., Maoret, M., Massa, F.G., and Svejenova, S. (2012), “Rebels with a Cause: Formation, Contestation, and Expansion of the De Novo Category ‘Modern Architecture’, 1870-1975’”, Organization Science, 23 (6): 1523-1545.
Kennedy, M.T., Lo, J., and Lounsbury, M. (2010), “Category Currency: The Changing Value of Conformity as a Function of Ongoing Meaning Construction”, Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 31: 369-397.
Khaire, M., and Wadhwani, R.D. (2010), “Changing Landscapes: The Construction of Meaning and Value in a New Market Category - Modern Indian Art”, Academy of Management Journal, 53 (6): 1281-1304.
Lamont, M., and Molnar, V. (2002), “The Study of Boundaries in the Social Sciences”, Annual Review of Sociology, 28: 167-195.
Legge Regionale 28 Dicembre 2012, n. 50, Politiche per lo Sviluppo del Sistema Commerciale nella Regione del Veneto. (BUR n. 110/2012), Regione Veneto.
Legge Regionale 4 Marzo 2019 , n. 4, Modifiche e Integrazioni alla Legge Regionale 30 Dicembre 2009, n. 33 (Testo Unico delle Leggi Regionali in Materia di Sanità): Abrogazione del Capo III 'Norme in Materia di Attività e Servizi Necroscopici, Funebri e Cimiteriali' del Titolo VI e Introduzione del Titolo VI Bis 'Norme in Materia di Medicina Legale, Polizia Mortuaria, Attività Funebre, Regione Lombardia.
Lee, B.H., Hiatt, S.R., and Lounsbury, M. (2017), “Market Mediators and the Trade-Offs of Legitimacy-Seeking Behaviors in a Nascent Category”, Organization Science, 28 (3): 447-470.
Mervis, C.B., and Rosch, E. (1981), “Categorization of Natural Objects”, Annual Review of Psychology, 32 (1): 89-115.
Meyer, R.E., and Höllerer, M.A. (2010), “Meaning Structures in a Contested Issue Field: A Topographic Map of Shareholder Value in Austria”, Academy of Management Journal, 53 (6): 1241-1262.
Modifiche all’Articolo 182 del Codice di cui al Decreto Legislativo 22 Gennaio 2004, n. 42, 14/02/2013.
Navis, C., and Glynn, M.A. (2010), “How New Market Categories Emerge: Temporal Dynamics of Legitimacy, Identity, and Entrepreneurship in Satellite Radio, 1990-2005”, Administrative Science Quarterly, 55 (3): 439-471.
Negro, G., Koçak, Ö., and Hsu, G. (2010), “Research on Categories in the Sociology of Organizations”, in G. Hsu, G. Negro and Ö. Koçak (eds), Categories in Markets: Origins and Evolution (Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Vol. 31), 3-35, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley. DOI: 10.1108/S0733-558X(2010)0000031003.
Negro, G., Hannan, M.T., and Rao, H. (2011), “Category Reinterpretation and Defection: Modernism and Tradition in Italian Winemaking”, Organization Science, 22 (5): 1449-1463.
Ocasio, W., Loewenstein, J., and Nigam, A. (2015), “How Streams of Communication Reproduce and Change Institutional Logics: The Role of Categories”, Academy of Management Review, 40 (1): 28-48.
Phillips, N., Lawrence, T., and Hardy, C. (2004), “Discourse and Institutions”, The Academy of Management Review, 29 (4): 635-652.
Rao, H., Monin, P., and Durand, R. (2005), “Border Crossing: Bricolage and the Erosion of Categorical Boundaries in French Gastronomy”, American Sociological Review, 70 (6): 968-991.
Risberg, A., Tienari, J., and Vaara, E. (2003), “Making Sense of a Transnational Merger: Media Texts and the (Re)Construction of Power Relations”, Culture and Organization, 9 (2): 121-137.
Roberts, M.E., Stewart, B.M., and Tingley, D. (2014), “stm: R Package for Structural Topic Models”, Journal of Statistical Software, 10 (2): 1-40.
Roberts, M., Stewart, B., and Tingley, D. (2019), stm Package. Available online at https://cran.usthb.dz/web/packages/stm/stm.pdf (last accessed: February 28, 2020).
Slavich, B., Svejenova, S., Opazo, M.P., and Patriotta, G. (2020), “Politics of Meaning in Categorizing Innovation: How Chefs Advanced Molecular Gastronomy by Resisting the Label”, Organization Studies, 41 (2): 267-290.
Vergne, J., and Wry, T. (2014), “Categorizing Categorization Research: Review, Integration, and Future Directions”, Journal of Management Studies, 51 (1): 56-93.
